A new chapter has emerged in the very public fallout between As I Lay Dying frontman Tim Lambesis and his ex-wife, Dany Ciara, following the release of Ciara’s recent appearance on the BREWtally Speaking podcast.
The nearly four-hour episode, released on December 28, featured Ciara expanding on past allegations of abuse and manipulation she has previously leveled against Lambesis. Their relationship unraveled publicly in late 2024, marked by competing statements, leaked footage, and accusations from both sides. Former members of As I Lay Dying have also linked the volatility surrounding the situation to the collapse of the band’s then-lineup. Since then, Lambesis has rebuilt the group with new members and resumed touring and releasing music.
Tim Lambesis Issues A Statement
Following Ciara’s podcast appearance, Lambesis released a statement addressing the renewed attention surrounding their past relationship. He framed his response as an effort to move forward and refocus on his work, while questioning the timing and context of Ciara’s claims.
“Hey @timlambesis
First, the claim that you “stayed quiet” about your personal life this whole time is actually crazy. This entire last year, you have publicly slandered and lied about what happened during our marriage on Instagram and Facebook portraying yourself as the victim, accusing me of many untrue things, that directly involved me, lying and rewriting the story to salvage your image.Second, framing my speaking now as “timing” “fixation” or “attachment” is a deflection. Attacking motive is a common way of yours to avoid engaging with substance. You’re talking about WHEN I spoke and WHY you think I spoke, but youre not actually addressing what I said. Survivors of abuse do not lose the right to tell the truth because time has passed, because the other person’s career has momentum, or because it’s inconvenient. Abuse doesn’t become “old stories” because the person who caused harm wants it buried. Sorry.
This has nothing to do with your career, your momentum, or your touring schedule. I’m speaking now because you refuse to stop lying and pretending you didn’t abuse me. I finally feel strong enough to tell the truth without fear of intimidation or silencing. Framing my speaking out around your Russian tours is manipulative and it doesn’t erase what happened or what you did.
You keep saying ” context matters”
On October 10th I texted you after seeing many of your public comments, and I called you out for your lies, suggesting that we both come forward with the truth, “l show all the evidence from my side, you show all the evidence for your side.” YOU REFUSED. Why is that? Should I show the context of everything that I talked about, and everything I didn’t talk about?I did not “break the silence”. I spoke after many of your public statements about me had already been made. When you say “context matters” you use that word as a shield while continuing to avoid specifics. If context truly mattered to you, you would address concrete behaviors rather than implying my obsession, dishonesty, or opportunism.
“if anything illegal had happened, it would have been addressed through proper channels”?
The idea that something isn’t real unless it’s prosecuted is crazy . Most abuse never goes through the legal system, and that doesn’t erase it. Many survivors never report abuse due to fear, coercion, financial control, retaliation, or safety concerns. A lack of prosecution is not proof of innocence, and it is not a reflection of lived experience.what exactly are you referring to that is so-called “illegal”? The screenshots of you having possession of illegal Al prnogrphy including a minor, are literally on the podcast, there’s proof of the context right there for you. Just because it wasn’t reported and you weren’t prosecuted doesn’t mean that it didn’t happen. Everything I talked about on the podcast I have proof for. Like I said. I am allowed to talk about the horrific shit that you did.
It’s also deeply hypocritical to suggest that my relationship history somehow discredits my credibility while ignoring your own. You are on your third marriage. You were convicted for attempting to have your first wife killed. You cheated on and abused your second wife. And despite all
of that, you expect people to believe that any pattern worth scrutinizing belongs only to me.
Invoking my past relationships is not context. You’re deflecting.
And it doesn’t negate a single thing I actually said about YOU.I’m aware of the scrutiny around why I married you given your history. I own my part in that. I wasn’t thinking clearly, I wasn’t healed, and I made decisions from a damaged place. That’s something I’ve been honest with myself about. What I won’t accept is the idea that my flaws somehow erase the abuse you inflicted. What is dishonest is using past relationship to imply that all of my experiences must be fabricated, in exaggerated or opportunistic. Multiple things can be true at the same time. I can acknowledge my own patterns and still be telling the truth about what happened in our relationship.
I go into great detail on the podcast about how I’ve spent the last year reflecting on myself and my own patterns of why I continue to gravitate towards toxic relationships, I never once claimed I am a perfect victim and I never once claimed that I have not been a part of that. But once again, that does not negate the abuse that you put me through. Minimizing me talking about abuse you put me through as “noise” or to me as someone who “attached” myself to you, is another pathetic attempt to shame me speaking into silence.
I am not attaching myself to you. I am telling my story.
I existed before you, and I exist after you. You don’t get to decide when I’m allowed to speak about what happened to me. You don’t get to reframe my truth as a nuisance to your career. Your work and music does not get veto power over my voice. I spoke honestly about my experience. I’m not asking for permission, validation, or approval. I’m correcting the record and reclaiming my narrative after too much of your public distortion and lies. I’m not going to back down to you, and you’re not going to shame me into silence.”
As of now, neither party has indicated whether further statements will follow. The situation continues to draw widespread attention within the heavy music community, given Lambesis’ history and As I Lay Dying’s ongoing activity.
Do you love independent bands, or are you in one? The Mosh Network is not just a rock/metal news website, but it doubles as an independent band directory, designed so that visitors can browse independent bands by not just subgenre, but location as well. It’s perfect to keep your finger on the pulse of your area’s hottest and newest bands or if you’re in a band, it’s a great way to find bands to network with! Click the banner below and start discovering bands all over the world, now!


74 Comments
Read more:
https://springgreen-caribou-353428.hostingersite.com/dany-ciara-statement-response-tim-lambesis-as-i-lay-dying/
He said/she said drama 🤦♂️
Jesse Frazier more like “he tried to have his first ex wife killed and then abused his second ex wife drama”
Tim is a freaking douchebag he got off way to easy
Chris Epley He did. He only served two years of a six year sentence. Not much justice in that.
Chris Epley refreshing to hear from a man because most comment sections are full of men victim blaming and downplaying his crimes. Thanks for being on the right side of history.
Era Tree Better not tell you that there are women who you would claim are victim blaming for not defending or being on her side 😂😂😂
David Jamieson and here you are. Loser behavior. Internalized misogyny is a thing, dumb ass.
Era Tree Aww bless calling me a dumb ass and loser behaviour for not defending victims and not defending Tim Aww bless you might want to try harder next time and think of something more developed in your next response 👍 Stated facts that there are tons of women who would be victim blaming according to you and all you could do was turn aggressive 😂😂😂 Internalised misogyny is a thing 😮 Are you serious 😮 and here was me thinking it was a item from a video game 😉
Feel free to carry on for my entertainment whilst I don’t defend Tim or her and just love the music new and old 👍
David Jamieson trying to read that gave me an aneurysm. why is it always the people defending domestic violence that type like they have the mental capacity of a boulder?
Mike Kelly Gonna half to try harder, tell me without making an ass wipe out of yourself where I defend domestic violence 🤷🏻♂️ But yeah can’t wait to be entertained by this 😉
Nobody cares.
Media: https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia.tenor.co%2FLLRqQ6-DRz0AAAAM%2Fwaiting-waiting-forever.gif&h=AT2-O_ALrGn35bOohOLTSnZC5O4Gj8SZGkGwTuKYU_DsnsjwDz6Vkkq9pAZlH_7uoZYZfRHVpmDkSlOx_u95DEvNBX-WA1bk3BJVXYlD8bmmPQzMF9M9U9hEpqXLwkD0&s=1
Media: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=122158480580869654&set=p.122158480580869654&type=3
Sounds like she’s guilty of something and makes it sound like she manipulated Tim into being crazy to the point of doing what he did. Not saying what Tim did was right but I mean sometimes we only see the retaliation not the initial act. Like Amber heard. Its not hard for me to believe Johnny Depp might be a controlling dickhead douchebag in some way. Look at his acting career and all the roles he’s had. That kinda fame had to go to his head. Tim hired a hitman. Amber took a shit on a bed
Robert Patterson Yes the guy who hired a hitman to murder his wife couldn’t possibly just be a complete waste of existence. It was the WOMEN who made him crazy.
”sure he tried to kill his wife, but how can I make that her fault?”
Robert Patterson “well it had to be the WOMAN who drove him to try to have his ex wife killed, scream in his second ex wifes face, and kick his dog!” get bent you lump.
Just here for the haters, whilst I still carry on loving his music new and old not giving two fecks about his personal life.
David Jamieson that doesn’t make you cool dude, it just makes you part of the problem
Aidan Millar-Powell Hi I would be interested to know where I mention trying to be cool 🤷🏻♂️ I would also like you to further explain without making a further fool out of yourself how I am part of the problem by not caring about his personal life and just enjoying the music because well guess what I don’t like what he did but it ain’t going to stop me enjoying his music, there are other musicians who have done worse ect and people still like them, if you don’t like him that’s your choice but it doesn’t make me part of the problem 👍 So erm yeah feel free to respond again for my entertainment 🙂
David Jamieson lol ok edgelord.. the guy is a pos and you’re the one making a “fool of yourself” or whatever.. big virgin energy dude, grow a spine.
You’re part of the problem because you are among the people who are willing to excuse his atrocious behaviour, he hired a hitman to kill his wife ffs and then abused another woman.. he’s been married three times..
Aidan Millar-Powell Thanks again for the entertainment and making an ass wipe out of yourself for me 🙂 Looks like I don’t need to grow anything but looks like you need to grow something called intelligence and well a brain 👍 Sorry you’re offended by people who love music 🙂
Now lesser developed human please state where I am willing to excuse his atrocious behaviour when I already stated (I DON’T LIKE WHAT HE DID) so lesser developed human please state where I excuse him ? when I don’t I just love the music sorry if what I am saying is too developed for you to understand 👍
Would you like to fail again for my entertainment and cry virgin again 😂😂
David Jamieson 😂😂 god you’re such a loser.. you literally said you don’t care what he did.. have a good day and go fuck yourself 👍
Aidan Millar-Powell It’s not nice to block when you have been made a fool out of, Love his music, love his voice, don’t like what he did, don’t care about his personal life, only the music. Sorry you don’t know shit hence why you ran away and blocked. Love lesser developed failures like you
David Jamieson bet you love Lostprophets lol
Mike Kelly Wondered when someone would try and use Lostprophets against me 😂 Just one problem I never listened to Lostprophets even before whatever his name was got exposed as a pedophile 👍 So erm yeah good shot but no luck, Better luck next time. Now to laugh in Varg who has loads of fans 😉
David Jamieson OH BOY YOU LIKE VARG TOO LOL. yea, you’re just like him. a pissbaby little edgelord who lives off the reactions of other people because nobody actually loves you 🙂
Mike Kelly Now Lesser developed failure if you are going to try hurt my feelings then actually try hurt my feelings, guess what failure I don’t even listen to Varg or Burzum 😉 I just knew mentioning a notorious metal singer who still has loads of fans would get a reaction from you. See I don’t need to live off reactions because if you were intelligent you would know people don’t have to react to me they choose to react, just like you choosing to react like a complete joke 👍 Should show you to my Transexual mates they would laugh at how pathetic you are, imagine being you and getting laughed at by transexual people.
Are you brave enough to talk shit in person if so send me a message with the time and place maybe invite you to a concert see how brave you are face to face since you are that pathetic you attack people who enjoy things you don’t 🙂
But yeah you want to be a real man, come meet face to face 🙂 Scotland’s waiting ❤️
Mike Kelly Are you ok now crybaby? Or would you like to be a real man and meet me face to face? Scotland awaits ❤️
Haha loser boy couldn’t defend himself so ran away and blocked me
David Jamieson you’re so cool 🙄
Brenden Martin Aww bless another booboo 👍 didn’t realise I was trying to be cool 🤷🏻♂️
Stay safe behind your keyboard now crying away since I don’t like what Tim did but love his music 👍
David Jamieson I mean we can meet in real life if you’d like. Marion, IN 🤷
We can either talk or we can run hands. So miss me with the “keyboard” statement. Either way Imma say the same thing to your face 🤙🤙
Stay safe “gangsta Dave” 🤣
Brenden Martin Sweet you live in Marion, IN, well little keyboard warrior send me a message with the time and date 🙂 Happy to say your a little Crybaby face to face.
Bless the only option from the lesser developed brain was look on my profile and mention a college joke nickname, love weak men who’s only option is check profiles to try to offend yet fail big time 🙂 Remember and send a message with the time and date coward.
David Jamieson hell yeah man, enabling genuine pieces of shit, because you can’t let go of nostalgia is the coolest 🤙🏼
Christopher Lewis Bradford Thanks for responding and clarifying intelligence wasn’t gifted upon you at birth. Now lesser developed birth please state where I am enabling pieces of shit by loving the music 🤷🏻♂️ I understand lesser developed people like you struggle with simple things like 1-1+0= ? Hence why you struggle to understand that even if Tim Lambesis didn’t make music anymore ect he would still be able to be the same person and he would still be able to go out and do the exact same thing again 👍
Carry on trying to be one of those failures all goody good good afraid to love music by controversial people because you need to fit in.
David Jamieson you try too hard dude 😅
Okay, but you gotta get over it
On top of all the hideous things he’s done, he’s even kicked a dog….
Melissa Gralewski at least it wasn’t a cat
She’s a hater after his money
Tony Valdez thats what I’m thinking, why now for all this media hype, its like how many years since hes been out of jail? Now that the band is blowing up again, it seems strange timing
When you state you don’t like what Tim did, but still enjoy the music so lesser developed people cry your defending Domestic abuse clarifying they aren’t capable of reading or just so arrogant they can’t handle the fact someone still loves the music but not the crime 👍
David Jamieson it’s the age old tale of “ love the art, not the artist”.
John Hillman Which is what I do, I love the art but not the artist yet some people don’t seem capable of understanding that so their only option is attacks and insults towards me.
Well every story has 3 versions theirs yours and the truth
Hi Aidan Millar-powell it’s not nice to run away and block like a little joke when your arse is handed to you on a golden platter.
Love Tim’s music, Don’t like what Tim did, Don’t give too fecks about his personal life only care about the music but don’t like what he did. So erm yeah not really hard to understand. Yeah I know your a little failure who’s only option was cry edgelord ect all because I love his music 👍 Enjoy being a failure 🙏🤘
So this fucking idiot didn’t read about him before she got with him
Jessica Anne Shh you are female so meant to defend her 😂😂 Rage mode haters incoming soon lol.
She’ll be doing OF soon 🤣
Tale as old as time
Give me another Austrian Death Machine!
Beau Peterson Rage mode haters incoming since you enjoy his music which they can’t handle
David Jamieson haha yeah I know. That’s ok though I’m still gonna blast it 🤘🏼
Haha dumb
Apparently she thought she could fix him
She’s had nothing to say for an entire year after they split but his new songs are doing numbers and she is likely seething about it. Looked like a mutually toxic relationship.
Jay Smitka she probably didn’t get much of a pay out when they got divorced so has to earn her money via slander instead.
Julia von Grover 😮😮😮 You are female you can’t say that you will upset people since you are female so obviously meant to automatically defend and praise Dany 😂😂😂
Jay SmitkaMedia: https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia4.giphy.com%2Fmedia%2Fv1.Y2lkPTk5OWFjZWFjYXpmdDdiaDc0MHRtYnh6MjBmbDdxamp0azliczVzanZ5aW52aXBteCZlcD12MV9naWZzX3NlYXJjaCZjdD1n%2FY11Y1zMBIWPIuU8XHn%2Fgiphy.gif&h=AT2NOCPC0b-FYzkYTfxc6k-Bx29ze0YKf277bsoBn1Ce0BSAuI4UlFZ0OX94MIDUJxAvgXXkHeSN377_3wTmbPEExTRsRC44JIuIMeXZ4fSUJ8r_Hq0BxEoBT9qvQjMU&s=1
Wait, What?Media: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1939066383618706&set=p.1939066383618706&type=3
He should just go gay there’s plenty of guys who like it rough and love guys on roids
Tim Lambesis is a piece of shit. There’s literal evidence showing it
Cue the victim shaming comments from abusive men.
I get it, he did a crime before and served his time. But I do think all of this is rather convenient when the band is getting successful again to come out.
The timing is impeccable
Classic Tren Lambesis.
Notice how nobody even knew who Dany Ciara was before she married Tim. Tim helped jumpstart her music career which makes me think she was also in it to get more exposure in the music industry, Tim collaborated her with other artist as well
So the guy who tried to have his last wife murdered and you guys don’t believe this?? Lmaooo
You got with him to get to this…..you wanted a lamb goat article and you knew he would get you there.
Be real, fuckin dork 🤡
Tim’s responses in social media look way better than hers on the surface. And the timing is impeccable, considering the current lineup, new music, and tours. 
Move on….life goes on. Fortunately or unfortunately