Former Mushroomhead vocalist Jeffrey “Nothing” Hatrix — a founding member who performed with the masked metal collective from 1993 through his departure in 2018 — has confirmed that his legal dispute with fellow co-founder Steve “Skinny” Felton has officially come to an end.
The conflict first became public in August 2024 when Hatrix filed a federal lawsuit against Felton and their shared business entity Filthy Hands Company. The suit centered on royalty payments tied to his contributions to the band’s catalog, with Hatrix asserting writing credits on more than one hundred Mushroomhead tracks.
Beyond the financial dispute, the filing alleged misconduct related to how funds were distributed, including claims of payments issued under alternate aliases and through third-party contractors. Hatrix sought monetary damages along with access to financial documentation tied to the matter as part of the legal action.
Taking to social media today (Feb. 9, 2026), Hatrix revealed that the dispute has now been resolved amicably, signaling a shift away from the tensions that previously surrounded the situation. He wrote:
“As a lot of you know, there has been an ongoing lawsuit between myself and my former band. I’m happy to report that the situation is settled and over.
From here out, there will be nothing negative about Mushroomhead or Skinny on my page. He came to the table amicably and honorably and we found a solution that made both of us happy.
Skinny and I founded Mushroomhead and it’s great to see the fanbase and community it has built. I’m proud of that and I know he is. Mushroomhead is his and I wish him the best. My creative baby is now my solo work. Will I ever work with Shroom again? Time will tell. I’m not against it. But I have no ill feelings either way. I want everybody to win.
Thank you all for your years of support and for having my back when it was needed, but from here on out it’s nothing but positivity in that direction. I said I was done with drama and I meant it. Love you guys!”
While details of the settlement were not disclosed, Hatrix’s statement suggests both parties reached a mutually agreeable resolution. His remarks also leave open the possibility — however uncertain — of future collaboration with the band he helped form, though he emphasized his current focus remains on his solo creative work.
If you’re rocking with The Mosh Network, hit the link and add us as a Preferred Source on Google. That’s the easiest way to keep our latest metal, hardcore, and alternative news, tours, and releases showing up directly in your feed.



39 Comments
Read more:
https://springgreen-caribou-353428.hostingersite.com/jeffrey-nothing-lawsuit-settled/
What was the lawsuit about?
Ricky Treas royalties dispute and other financial misconduct
Lawsuit???
Wholly phuck
I think the only reason why they’re doing this is because they don’t really own mushroomhead anymore. I don’t even think skinny’s in the band mushroom had anymore
Euria O’Dell Skinny is still in the band. He is the only original member.
Jeromy Shaffer yea that n bat is kinda original I think loll
Joel Brady Bat or Ryan isn’t not an original member. He literally replaced the guy that replaced the original member who in fact is that guys brother 😆 🤣
Matthew Aviña ahh okk loll I thought he was my bad n yeaa pumpernickel n pig benis are the OG members now in Ex faces
Jeromy Shaffer pig is not an og his brother was the original bass player
Matthew Aviña I’ve been out of the Mushroomhead Loop for a while. You talkn about JJ?
Jimmy Conley No I’m talking about their original bassist Mr. Murdernickel who was replaced by his brother Pig Benis who was replaced by Dr. F or the Bat as OP called him 😆
Matthew Aviña oh ok. I remember Pig. I was at pretty much every mrh show up to the 3rd studio album in Cleveland. I only go now when I get free tickets 😁.
I was friends with JJ’s cousin in middle/high school. An ex was a stripper with one of Jeff’s ex’s in Cleveland. I think she fkd J-man once actually ( slut lol).
Anyway, ahh to be young again😅
Jeromy Shaffer also Dave Felton original member as well.
Shawn Bennett Dave wasn’t a member till 7 years after. The band started in 1993. Dave came in 2000
Euria O’Dell you should definitely do some research before you start yapping… Skinny is the main reason why we have a completely different band… Unlike clown and corey from slipknot , skinny doesn’t know how to take care of anyone , but himself and his band is now garbage
Euria O’Dell the last 2 times I seen MRH Skinny didn’t even play drums and one time I seen them and there wasn’t any original members.
what about j mann and waylon did they catch wind of it as well
Thunder Bird they already know what’s going on.
Now he can join the new band and play with the real mushroomhead…woohoo
Zach Hooper said will never happen 😭
Brian Freimark He did a bit back. More recently, he said he’d be open to something if everything aligned, but he’s focusing on his own work for the time being.
Ben Hughes He stated in the comments OF THAT LAWSUIT POST, that he will not be joining the ex-faces.
Zach Hooper sadly he said he’d never play with them
Even though that’s what the real fans want
who else thought he was the new member to the ex faces lol
Fingers crossed it happens!
Andrew Hewitt Jeffrey recently said he hasn’t ruled it out. It’s just for now, he wants to focus on his own work.
Ben HughesMedia: https://l.facebook.com/l.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fmedia1.tenor.co%2Fm%2F8y9rx0HMW9EAAAAC%2Fjoke-u-joke.gif&h=AT3JHAXncVdkfFXg9gdCiP2ki5IR5mDOQ-Q_Balk9kvZoqWYosDr4BuKAWXsVfHOABLnCaM3mE8eFtzUIFLSIDW5sl52zDDqysuwiUcaDBBeotDoRppwZUHGkLAFZdrF&s=1
Andrew Hewitt no one
Joshua A Freeman no his band was called nothing
Looks like Robin Williams
Give this man his 20 bucks!
Skinny has screwed over so many people that this should’ve been a class action lawsuit lol.
What happen to mushroomhead and I heard of Jeffery nothing is the new band? Mushroomhead is like a break up like ill nino did and they suck now
Roland LaPointe theres still a version of mushroomhead with the drummer his gf and all new members.
Jeffery nothing is doing a solo album and tour
Like 8 or 9 ex mushroomhead members are in a band called the x faces doing classic era mushroomhead songs
Mushroomhead sucks now, everybody knows that dirty bitch ruined the band.
Isnt Jmann an original member?
Shaun Brewer yes
Shawn Bennett i meant for that to be a reply to someones comment but ended up here they were talking original members and noone mentioned jmann